Cottolio Naples Air Fryer Review: My Pizza Results

Affiliate Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Disclosure: Cottolio sent me the Naples air fryer free to try. If you buy it through my link, I may earn a commission from Cottolio. The opinions and cooking results shared here are my own.

Sale update (November 19): When I checked Amazon, the Cottolio Naples air fryer was on sale for $124! Check the listing for the latest price.

I use my air fryer all the time, so when I had the opportunity to try the Cottolio Naples pizza air fryer, I was excited! I especially love how an air fryer crisps up leftover pizza. I’m a crunchy girl, so a crispy crust is a big deal to me.

A roomy air fryer designed with pizza in mind? I definitely wanted to give it a try.

Cottolio Naples air fryer on my kitchen counter

After making two homemade pizzas, a frozen pizza, frozen battered cod, and homemade potato chips, I’m sharing my opinions. Some things turned out great. The pizza crust, however, wasn’t quite what I was hoping for…it might be a me problem LOL.

If you’re considering the Cottolio Naples air fryer, here’s what I liked, a few things to keep in mind, and whether I would spend my own money on it…its one of a couple largest air fryer brands I’ve used!

I also own a Ninja Flip SP151 that I love, so I’ll share how the Cottolio compares with the air fryer toaster oven I already use at home.

Cottolio Naples air fryer on a kitchen table top. Text reads: Cottolio Naples Air Fryer Review: What I liked & what I’d do differently.”

My Quick Take on the Cottolio Naples Air Fryer

The roomy cooking area and viewing windows are my favorite features. My frozen battered cod came out crispy and golden, too!

But with all three pizzas I tried, the toppings and cheese were more done than I wanted before the bottom crust reached the crispness I prefer. Changing the crust thickness, cooking time, temperature, and rack position didn’t give me the results I was looking for.

The Cottolio is also a BIG appliance. If you cook large amounts regularly and have plenty of counter space, the size is a real plus! If you’re buying it mainly for crispy pizza crust, my results so far might make me hesitate.

Cottolio Naples air fryer on my kitchen counter with frozen pepperoni pizza next to it not cooked yet

First impressions: this is a big air fryer!

The first thing that struck me was the size. I was impressed by how much room it had, but I also had to think about where it would live in my kitchen!

Cottolio lists the Naples as an 8.4-quart air fryer with room for up to a 12-inch pizza. It also highlights stainless steel on food-contact surfaces. The huge cooking area was one of the things that interested me.

I have a lot of counter space in my kitchen. Even so, appliances need to earn the right to be there because I do a lot of cooking for large family dinners and need counter space.

The huge cooking area will be great for larger batches and family meals. I haven’t tested every kind of food or a full family-size batch yet…except the Cod and Chips, but I also appreciated having room for a whole frozen pizza. 

Frozen pizza with browned cheese in the Cottolio air fryer basket

What’s included?

Mine came with the air fryer, a pizza rack, a lower baking/crisper accessory, instructions, and a little recipe booklet…I liked that it also came with a quick start guide so I could get it up and running right away.

what comes with the Cottolio Pizza air fryer, basket, crisper plate, pizza rack, heating chamber.

There are preset settings for pizza, wings, and frozen fries, labeled “chips,” plus a manual mode for other foods. You can adjust the time and temperature on all of them so you’re not stuck with just the preset.

Top of the Cottolio Air Fryer showing all of the presettings and manual settings.

I also like the viewing windows. Being able to see the food cooking is a useful feature, especially when I’m keeping an eye on how quickly the top is browning.

I loved also that it came with a quick start guide, full instructions and a recipe booklet.

Cottolio recipe book, instructions booklet and quick start guide

My Homemade Pizza Results

Since this is a pizza air fryer, pizza was what I was most interested in testing. I tried my usual homemade crust first, then my homemade crust that is much thinner.

My usual thicker crust pizza

My first homemade pizza had my usual thicker crust, although it wasn’t an especially thick pizza.

The cheese and toppings were fully done before the bottom was the way I like it. The crust was cooked, but the underside was very soft.

Now, my husband actually liked it this way! So there is definitely some personal preference involved here. If you enjoy a softer crust, you might feel differently about the results.

For me, though, it needed more crispness underneath.

My Very Thin Crust Pizza

I thought a thinner crust might solve the problem. I was pretty confident it would, actually. It didn’t.

I adjusted the cooking time and temperature, but the top still finished before the bottom reached the texture I wanted. Across my pizza tests, I also tried the pizza rack and the lower baking accessory without getting the crispy bottom I was hoping for.

I’m sharing what happened in my kitchen, rather than trying to diagnose why. My experience was that the toppings browned before the bottom reached my preferred crispness

How did frozen pizza turn out?

I wondered whether frozen pizza might be a better match for this appliance, so I tried that next. One thing I can say is that the cooking area holds a good-size pizza comfortably. That was nice!

The pizza tasted good, but I had a similar result: the top browned before I felt the bottom crust was ready.

Cutting the cooked frozen pepperoni pizza with a pizza cutter.

The slice stayed soft enough to flop over when I held it up. That doesn’t tell you everything about doneness, but it does show the texture I was getting instead of the crisp bottom I prefer.

Slice of frozen pizza bending downward when held up

Again, I’m a crunchy girl. I want that little bit of crispness when I bite into a slice, and I haven’t gotten it with this air fryer YET. As with all new appliances…there’s an experimental stage for sure.

What else have I cooked in the Cottolio Pizza air fryer?

Frozen Battered Cod

The frozen battered cod turned out great! It was crispy and golden, which is exactly what I wanted.

That was a much better result for me than the pizza crust, and a reminder that I still have other foods I want to try before deciding whether this appliance earns a permanent spot on my counter.

Homemade potato chips

First test: I also tried homemade potato chips without adding oil. I wasn’t happy with that batch: some pieces were more done than others, and they didn’t have the flavor I wanted or texture I wanted.

Second test: I used a little cooking spray. The homemade potato chips turned out fantastic in the Cottolio…probably the best I’ve made! YUM!

Crispy air fried potato chips on a white plate

Cleaning and handling the basket

I’ve put the removable basket and racks in the dishwasher, which makes cleanup so easy!

One thing to know: I find the basket heavy, especially when it’s full of hot food. Have a clear, heat-safe place ready before you pull it out, and use hot pads for protection from the heat.

The size is great, but it’s worth thinking about the weight as well as the counter space.

What I Like and What to Keep in Mind

What I Like
To Keep in Mind

LARGE cooking area

Takes up a large amount of counter space

Nice Viewing windows

Loaded basket is heavy

Adjustable presets and manual controls

Pizza tops browned before the crust reached my preferred crispness. but pizza was still good!

Crispy, golden results with battered Cod & Chips.

This appliance is reasonably priced on sale.

Easy cleanup and removable parts

I haven’t used it long enough to judge durability but it seems well made!

Cottolio vs. my Ninja Flip Air Fryer Toaster Oven

I already have a Ninja Flip SP151, which was also a gift, and I love using it.

These are the largest air fryers I’ve personally used. When I put them side by side, both took up a good amount of space. My Ninja isn’t a little appliance either!

Cottolio Naples and Ninja Flip air fryers side by side on the counter

The difference is what happens when I’m finished cooking. My Ninja folds up, giving me counter space back between uses. The Cottolio doesn’t fold up, so it keeps its full footprint unless I move it somewhere else.

Ninja Flip folded upright beside the Cottolio Naples air fryer

How Does the Pizza Crust Compare?

I’ve made pizza in my Ninja, and I know it can produce the crisp crust I like. A note worth mentioning is that my Ninja is an air fryer toaster oven and that may be part of the reason why the crust is crispy. That’s part of why I was excited to try an appliance specifically marketed for pizza.

With the Cottolio, I haven’t gotten that same crisp bottom yet, even after trying different crust thicknesses, settings, and rack positions.

This wasn’t some kind of controlled test LOL with identical pizzas cooked side by side. It’s just my experience cooking with both appliances in my own kitchen. However the pizza was still good!

partial picture of pepperoni pizza just remvoed from air fryer
What Matters to Me
Cottolio Naples
Ninja Flip

Size I need – large

Large appliance with a huge basket

Also a large appliance

Counter Space between uses

Keeps its full footprint unless moved

Folds up to reclaim my counter space

Pizza crust in my experience

Softer underneath than I prefer (but cooked)

Has produced the crisp crust I enjoy

Time I’ve been using it

Still testing it – so far like it

Have owned and used it for years – love

Both Air Fryers were gifts, and they are appliances I’d have to think carefully about my budget before buying either with my own money…they are both a little pricey…except the Cottolio goes on sale quite often. For me, the value comes down to how well they cook the foods I make regularly, durability, easy clean up (I need that) and how they fit into my kitchen.

Is the Cottolio Naples air fryer worth buying?

At the time of writing, November, 2026, the Cottolio Naples Air Fryer is listed at $329.00 on the manufacturer’s website. Amazon’s current price for the Cottolio Naples on November 19, is $124 right now!!

For me, that is a lot to spend on an air fryer…however with sale price…I’d purchase it.

I can see the very roomy cooking area appealing to someone who has lots of kitchen space, cooks larger quantities, wants an easy clean up and uses an air fryer constantly.

But based on the pizzas I’ve made so far, I wouldn’t personally buy it specifically for a crisp pizza crust. I wanted the bottom to crisp up more before the cheese and toppings became so browned. But again…the pizza’s were still good and I have a crunchy appetite.

It feels well made to me, but I haven’t had it long enough to tell you how it holds up over time.

For now, I’m still deciding whether it earns its place on my counter…and I’m still testing other foods I love to cook in an air fryer.  I love the large cooking space and the viewing windows, and the Cod and Chips were a success. The pizza results is the only thing keeping me from giving it an amazing yes.

You can check the deets on this video page on Amazon for the Cottolio Naples air fryer.

Do you like a soft pizza crust, or are you a crunchy-crust person like me?

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 × four =